I
was recommended this work by a poster on a baseball forum, which I
suppose is as good a place as any to get history recommendations.
Recognized (not just by baseball enthusiasts!) as a comprehensive place
to begin study of the Spanish Civil War, it's long(ish), detailed,
heavily footnoted, with an extensive bibliography, and revised several
times (most recently in 2011) to ensure that it reflects the most
up-to-date scholarship on the subject.
Am I enough of an
expert on the Spanish Civil War that I can say whether or not this is
the best introductory work on the subject? No, of course not. Thomas
doesn't trip my bullshit detector, for the most part (which is worth something
in a conflict that still arouses strong feelings among late era
partisans), and he generally does try to puncture some of the myths told
about the conflict. Where he does appear to get a lot of criticism is
for glossing over the Spanish Revolution (the anarchist movement in
Catalonia, among other places), but I feel he covers this in a decent
amount of detail. (Although I will reserve further judgment until I've
read some more).
I'd recommend this, potentially to another reader on a baseball forum.
Showing posts with label history. Show all posts
Showing posts with label history. Show all posts
Monday, September 19, 2016
The Spanish Civil War
Labels:
anarchism,
communism,
fascism,
history,
Hugh Thomas,
Nazi,
non-fiction,
reading,
Spain,
Spanish Civil War
Wednesday, September 7, 2016
Island on Fire
Island on Fire is a fun little book that shows the importance of good primary sourcing. Witze and Kanipe draw very heavily on the diary of Jon Steingrimsson, a parish priest at the time of the eruption of Laki.
This is where I hear "Laki? I don't know of a volcano by that name," which is true for the intended audience of this book. Laki being a volcano that erupted in 1783 in Iceland, having a devastating effect on the community served by Jon (as our authors call him), and serious effects on the climate of both Europe and the Northern hemisphere as a whole.
From the community overview we move to Europe and the rest of the world, finishing with a look at Iceland today and potentially disruptive volcanoes around the world. It's a short, easy read, and a fun pop science look at something most of us are unfamiliar with.
This is where I hear "Laki? I don't know of a volcano by that name," which is true for the intended audience of this book. Laki being a volcano that erupted in 1783 in Iceland, having a devastating effect on the community served by Jon (as our authors call him), and serious effects on the climate of both Europe and the Northern hemisphere as a whole.
From the community overview we move to Europe and the rest of the world, finishing with a look at Iceland today and potentially disruptive volcanoes around the world. It's a short, easy read, and a fun pop science look at something most of us are unfamiliar with.
Labels:
Alexandra Witze,
fire sermon,
history,
Iceland,
Jeff Kanipe,
Jon Steingrimsson,
Laki,
non-fiction,
reading,
volcano
Monday, January 11, 2016
Legacy of Ashes
Legacy of Ashes is a pretty damning read (so damning that it merits a review/rebuttal on the CIA's official website, which I did not find particularly convincing). Weiner takes his title from Eisenhower, describing the failures of building a capable intelligence agency.
Legacy of Ashes is a bit frustrating, in that two repeating themes are that the agency can't find good analysts and/or covert operatives, and that the agency is constantly bleeding talent. Which is it? It could be turnover (employees hired, trained, then leave immediately for more lucrative work in the private sector, as Weiner documents happening during the Iraq War), or it's inconsequential, because these people don't know what they're doing, anyway. The CIA's rank-and-file, when they are mentioned, don't come off particularly well -- unable to speak foreign languages, unfamiliar with cultures, continually producing bad analysis, etc.
Legacy of Ashes reads as a litany of obfuscation, willful ignorance, and legerdemain on the part of the CIA's various directors (particularly Allen Dulles), and their attitudes towards the rest of the government, as well as other members of the CIA. There are times in the 50s (as well as the 60s, and 70s) where the right hand (analysis) didn't know what the left hand (covert action) was doing. I don't think any of the Presidents come off well, either; either asking the CIA to act against its charter, or authorizing missions with sketchy scope.
Unfortunately, it feels like Weiner starts skimming towards the end of the book. Some of this just may be due to events beyond his control, in that it's more easy to have something declassified from fifty years ago, as opposed to five-to-ten. But the agency does start to come across a little better post-Vietnam, even with the Latin American meddling and arms-for-hostages.
This is a pretty damning indictment, even if it is less than perfect; it paints a picture of an agency that has difficulty finding its ass with both hands, and given US foreign policy post-World War II, that unfortunately sounds about right. Worth reading to just shake your head.
Legacy of Ashes is a bit frustrating, in that two repeating themes are that the agency can't find good analysts and/or covert operatives, and that the agency is constantly bleeding talent. Which is it? It could be turnover (employees hired, trained, then leave immediately for more lucrative work in the private sector, as Weiner documents happening during the Iraq War), or it's inconsequential, because these people don't know what they're doing, anyway. The CIA's rank-and-file, when they are mentioned, don't come off particularly well -- unable to speak foreign languages, unfamiliar with cultures, continually producing bad analysis, etc.
Legacy of Ashes reads as a litany of obfuscation, willful ignorance, and legerdemain on the part of the CIA's various directors (particularly Allen Dulles), and their attitudes towards the rest of the government, as well as other members of the CIA. There are times in the 50s (as well as the 60s, and 70s) where the right hand (analysis) didn't know what the left hand (covert action) was doing. I don't think any of the Presidents come off well, either; either asking the CIA to act against its charter, or authorizing missions with sketchy scope.
Unfortunately, it feels like Weiner starts skimming towards the end of the book. Some of this just may be due to events beyond his control, in that it's more easy to have something declassified from fifty years ago, as opposed to five-to-ten. But the agency does start to come across a little better post-Vietnam, even with the Latin American meddling and arms-for-hostages.
This is a pretty damning indictment, even if it is less than perfect; it paints a picture of an agency that has difficulty finding its ass with both hands, and given US foreign policy post-World War II, that unfortunately sounds about right. Worth reading to just shake your head.
Labels:
CIA,
Cold War,
espionage,
history,
intelligence,
non-fiction,
reading,
spy,
Tim Weiner
Sunday, January 3, 2016
God's Chinese Son
God's Chinese Son came highly recommended to me, and I can't quite decide if it truly measures up to those praises. On the one hand, going into this, I knew almost nothing about the Taiping Rebellion, or Hong Xiuquan, the man who led it. From that perspective, this is a success, in that I'm conversant in what happened. But I don't feel that Spence did a great job placing the rebellion in context, or revealing its scope, or the long-lasting effects; it almost feels like my copy has lacunae of several chapters. I will praise Spence strongly for his placement of one chapter, though -- just as I was wondering "what do the Westerners in China, especially the missionaries and representatives of foreign governments, think of Hong Xiuquan's pecular brand of Christianity?" Immediately after thinking this, I turned the page to a chapter devoted to answering that question.
Not that this was an easy job for Spence; the tenth chapter, "Earth War" begins as follows:
The chapters that follow trace out the rebellion (some historians prefer to use "civil war") more or less chronologically, with the occasional stopping/retracing of steps to more fully flesh out another figure (such as the "East King", Yang Xiuqing, who was alleged to speak with the voice of God). Notes are extensive, although more often than not, they just point to a source and do not elaborate on the point. Mildly unfortunate.
While I feel that this is occasionally missing something (not context, but maybe a bigger picture), this is something I would strongly recommend.
Not that this was an easy job for Spence; the tenth chapter, "Earth War" begins as follows:
This is then followed by a litany of potential military moves: Hong Xiuquan wearing imperial yellow, instructions from Jesus to fight, the assembling and arming of troops, the posting of sentries, the lighting of signal fires, et cetera, before initial armed conflict begins, and Hong Xiuquan proclaims the Taiping Heavenly KingdomThere is no precise moment at which we can say the Taiping move from tension with the Qing state to open confrontation, but clearly in 1850 their provocations mount steadily until war becomes inevitable.
The chapters that follow trace out the rebellion (some historians prefer to use "civil war") more or less chronologically, with the occasional stopping/retracing of steps to more fully flesh out another figure (such as the "East King", Yang Xiuqing, who was alleged to speak with the voice of God). Notes are extensive, although more often than not, they just point to a source and do not elaborate on the point. Mildly unfortunate.
While I feel that this is occasionally missing something (not context, but maybe a bigger picture), this is something I would strongly recommend.
Labels:
China,
Christianity,
God,
history,
Hong Xiuquan,
Jesus,
Jonathan D. Spence,
non-fiction,
reading,
Taiping Rebellion
Monday, December 21, 2015
The Guns of August
I'm not sure if there's anything I can say about Barbara Tuchman's The Guns of August
that hasn't been said already. It's nothing if not tight, though --
yes, it's not a short work, and the subject matter isn't easily and
quickly distilled, but Tuchman retains her focus throughout.
Tuchman starts with the funeral of King Edward VII in 1910:
How many children witness something that impresses them enough in early childhood to write a book featuring the incident? How many of those stories would be noteworthy? As a child, Tuchman (along with her family) witnessed the German battlecruiser SMS Goeben's mad dash across the Mediterranean to Constantinople, fleeing British pursuit, who had realized too late that she wasn't making a break for the Atlantic. In a paper move, she was purchased by the Ottoman government, and spent the rest of the war in their service. Tuchman (as she notes in the introduction) was fascinated by this, and incorporates it into her narrative. Is it wholly necessary? Not entirely, but it helps set the stage of the naval war. I would have preferred the Battle of the Falkland Islands have been incorporated, but that was in December, rather than August (although Tuchman sometimes reaches into early September and October)
I'm not sure that I know enough about the First World War to say that this is a comprehensive account of August 1914, but there's a wealth of information here, about both what actually happened, and the motivations of those actors, drawn from letters and memoirs.
I was honestly hoping this would be more about the July Crisis, but Tuchman's extensive account of the first month is so masterful, I was very disappointed when it ended on the eve of the First Battle of the Marne. Recommended highly.
Tuchman starts with the funeral of King Edward VII in 1910:
and moves with deftness through the pre-war conditions, of the Germans, the French, the Russians, and the British, as well as the psychology that drove those plans -- of Kaiser Wilhelm, of the French generals, of the Czar and the general staff, and the British government."the greatest assemblage of royalty and rank ever gathered in one place and, of its kind, the last."
How many children witness something that impresses them enough in early childhood to write a book featuring the incident? How many of those stories would be noteworthy? As a child, Tuchman (along with her family) witnessed the German battlecruiser SMS Goeben's mad dash across the Mediterranean to Constantinople, fleeing British pursuit, who had realized too late that she wasn't making a break for the Atlantic. In a paper move, she was purchased by the Ottoman government, and spent the rest of the war in their service. Tuchman (as she notes in the introduction) was fascinated by this, and incorporates it into her narrative. Is it wholly necessary? Not entirely, but it helps set the stage of the naval war. I would have preferred the Battle of the Falkland Islands have been incorporated, but that was in December, rather than August (although Tuchman sometimes reaches into early September and October)
I'm not sure that I know enough about the First World War to say that this is a comprehensive account of August 1914, but there's a wealth of information here, about both what actually happened, and the motivations of those actors, drawn from letters and memoirs.
I was honestly hoping this would be more about the July Crisis, but Tuchman's extensive account of the first month is so masterful, I was very disappointed when it ended on the eve of the First Battle of the Marne. Recommended highly.
Labels:
Barbara Tuchman,
history,
non-fiction,
reading,
World War I
Monday, September 21, 2015
The Devil in the White City
Erik Larson's The Devil in the White City is widely praised, and it's easy to see why. It's a meticulously researched work that alternates chapters on the planning of the 1893 World's Fair with the activities of the serial killer H. H. Holmes, who operated in and around Chicago at the time. At least, the planning and architecture chapters are meticulously researched; the Holmes chapters are full of speculation, as he didn't document his activities the way the Fair's architects did; most of Holmes' actions are thus from informed speculation or forensics. (This isn't a problem unless one is going to insist on strict historical accuracy, as Larson is certainly an entertaining writer)
As a work of history that reads like a novel, this is absolutely a success. Obviously, this is not a novel, or we would have our major characters (Burnham and Olmstead on the architecture/planning side, and Holmes) intersect at or near the climax of the novel. Happily, they remain unaware of each other (Holmes was more interested in young, single women, being who he was). The closest we have to something like that is a subplot revolving around the eventual assassination of Carter Harrison, by a Guiteau-like office seeker.
Definitely recommended.
As a work of history that reads like a novel, this is absolutely a success. Obviously, this is not a novel, or we would have our major characters (Burnham and Olmstead on the architecture/planning side, and Holmes) intersect at or near the climax of the novel. Happily, they remain unaware of each other (Holmes was more interested in young, single women, being who he was). The closest we have to something like that is a subplot revolving around the eventual assassination of Carter Harrison, by a Guiteau-like office seeker.
Definitely recommended.
Sunday, November 30, 2014
Ford: We Never Called Him Henry
I was expecting a lot more from Ford: We Never Called Him Henry. It's very bare bones -- given the "as told to . . ." it reads like a series of anecdotes told over drinks or dinner. There's little context, few conclusions, and the editorial notes (not the words of Mr. Bennett) are dry and rarely relevant.
At least it's an easy read, but even as a supplement to the history of Ford, there's not much here.
At least it's an easy read, but even as a supplement to the history of Ford, there's not much here.
Labels:
automobile,
biography,
Ford,
Harry Bennett,
Henry Ford,
history,
memoir
Friday, November 28, 2014
Shattered Sword
Shattered Sword offers a new perspective on the Battle of Midway -- previous English accounts had been based off of mainly American combat records, and a few Japanese sources. The authors here have seen some primary Japanese sources (ships' logs, etc) translated into English for the first time, and as such are able to provide clarification on how events actually occurred.
Worth checking out if you're very interested in this particular area of history.
Worth checking out if you're very interested in this particular area of history.
Sunday, November 23, 2014
The Black Jacobins
C.L.R. James' The Black Jacobins is a classic for a reason. What we have is a fascinating narrative of how the Haitian Revolution stemmed from and paralleled the French, as well as how the slave result took the ideals of the French Revolution to their logical end.
James builds a clear narrative that is usually easy to follow, pointing out and correcting errors and misconceptions that other historians have had or perpetuated.
One of the issues with James is that he'll introduce a figure in passing, then repeatedly refer to him later. I'm not sure his index is always good at picking up the first reference to some of the more obscure figures, either.
Probably the biggest criticism I have of this work is that James is occasionally oblique -- he doesn't elaborate well on why the conflict between L'Ouverture and Rigaud was inevitable or necessary. And will occasionally refer to something he'd elaborated on previously as only the "[date] incident", which necessitates flipping back and forth.
An interesting part of the work is how obviously written from a socialist perspective it is, as James interprets events leading up to, and of both revolutions through the (as yet unwritten) lens of Marx. Some of these interpretations are insightful, but other times James ascribes feelings to the people (typically the French peasants) that they may not necessarily have held.
Another interesting part of the work is how James casts the anti-slavery efforts of the British as not motivated solely by altruism and a belief in justice/equality/etc, but in that Haiti required much more slave labor than any British possession, and the colony would have been economically crippled without it. Thus, British anti-slavery sentiment was propped up by a desire to harm France's interests.
I don't know if this is the definitive work on the Haitian Revolution (initially published in 1938, and James annotates his references in the second edition, that this was written during European domination of Africa, and prior to the Second World War), but it's well worth the read.
Thursday, March 24, 2011
Homage to Catalonia/Down and Out in Paris and London
In Homage to Catalonia, it's easy to see the ideas behind both Animal Farm and Nineteen Eighty-Four taking shape. Orwell's experiences in the militia fighting against Franco's coup are similar to Michael Shaara's sketches of Gettysburg in The Killer Angels, in that they're an inset, rather than the complete picture. (Of course, this is significantly more forgiveable in Orwell's case, since he's writing about his experiences, rather than about the scope of the coup and the subsequent war)If I wasn't aware of the history, I would think that the final third of this book was embellished -- street battles between members of the same side during a civil war? I've seen it argued that the Soviet Union's assistance hurt the Left in Spain more than it helped, and after reading this, it's certainly a perspective I have to take seriously.
Overall, this is a fascinating work, both from its perspective on soldiering in an unfamiliar land, as well as Orwell's analysis of the political situation (which, until the end, he keeps in separate chapters, which is a nice touch if one wants to focus on one or the other). What is obvious to us over sixty years later (that the USSR's purpose in Spain was to advance its own foreign policy, rather than necessarily to help the Republicans) was tragically not so during the war, much to the detriment of the dead.
The second work in this book, Down and Out in Paris and London, shows Orwell's socialism in if not quite an inchoate form, at least not at its final stage of development. The descriptions of the lives of poverty led by waitstaff, tramps, and residents of cheap hotels are real, but the feeling is similar to Pulp's "Common People":
cos when you're laid in bed at night,In short, that Orwell is living like this to have a taste of the life, not because he has no alternatives. This is illustrated when, fed up with working fifteen hour days underground as a "plongeur" (a dishwasher/errand boy), he writes a friend in London, who is able to get him a job quickly, so Orwell is able to leave his (miserable, but not untypical) fifteen hour workday.
watching roaches climb the wall,
if you call your Dad he could stop it all
The second portion of Down and Out in Paris and London is along the same lines -- when Orwell arrives in London, and is informed that his position will not be ready for a month, he decides to spend the time slumming, sleeping in workhouses and public dormitories. Here, the conditions are truly appalling, and Orwell does meet some fascinating characters. However, he does occasionally slip into lecturing, but that can be forgiven in such a young (at the time) author.
Clearly, Down and Out in Paris in London is no longer quite relevant -- not because no one in major Western cities lives or works in poor conditions, but because the conditions described here no longer exist. It is a worthwhile document of a bygone time, and it's worthwhile to see a young Orwell's ideas taking shape. Homage to Catalonia is, in my opinion, the more significant and interesting work here.
Labels:
anarchism,
communism,
fascism,
history,
non-fiction,
poverty,
Pulp,
Spain,
Spanish Civil War
Saturday, February 19, 2011
The Killer Angels
I have never heard of a historical novel quite like Michael Shaara’s Pulitzer Prize-winning effort; while other novels certainly feature equal or greater depths of research, Shaara is alone, as far as I know, in using only primary sources in his attempt to bring to life the Battle of Gettysburg. In a brief (one page) note, Shaara explains why he did so thusly:You may find it a different story from the one you learned in school. There have been many versions of that battle and that war. I have therefore avoided historical opinions and gone back primarily to the words of the men themselves, their letters and other documents. I have not consciously changed any fact. I have condensed some of the action, for the sake of clarity, and eliminated some minor characters, for brevity; but though I have often had to choose between conflicting viewpoints, I have not knowingly violated the action.Shaara also cites Stephen Crane's The Red Badge of Courage as an inspiration for his novel -- that reading history isn't enough to induce the feeling of being there. Of course, this raises the question as to what liberties Shaara took -- what minor characters he eliminated or condensed, and why was this done? (Although, who needs a dozen different aides to a general when one will do?)
The Killer Angels is split into chapters in which the narration is focused on one man, from a third person perspective. I believe this is the best way to convey the scope of the planning, buildup, and execution of the battle, as Shaara rotates the viewpoint with each chapter (although the narration remains third person omniscient). The biggest criticism of this usage is that the thoughts of the most recurring characters (Longstreet for the Confederacy, and Colonel Chamberlain for Union) can get repetitive -- Longstreet constantly despairing of his inability to persuade Lee to engage in a more defensive posture, and Chamberlain doting on his younger brother, Tom. It is precisely because of this narrative structure that The Killer Angels succeeds as a humanistic portrait of the battle, rather than a historical analysis -- real people can be tedious and repetitive.
While I don't have the historical chops to go into whether or not Shaara's narrative is a) faithful to the sources he worked from and b) in line with what modern historians believe, I feel that I should point out that after the battle begins, he neglects to mention much beyond Little Round Top (because that's where Chamberlain was, and where Longstreet, on Lee's orders, attacked) and Pickett's Charge (because Longstreet and Chamberlain were again both involved). While the action on Little Round Top and the Federal center were not inconsequential to the battle, other areas of engagement are glossed over. So while the novel is large in scope, it seems almost narrow here.
The Killer Angels is a worthwhile, easy read, and certainly made me want to look more into the Civil War in general, and the Battle of Gettysburg in particular. In that respect, it is a smashing success. Is it a worthy Pulitzer winner, though? Out of the winners I have read, I would rank it next to last, ahead of only Jhumpa Lahiri's Interpreter of Maladies.
Monday, October 12, 2009
To Rule the Waves
Perhaps the most disappointing part of Arthur Herman's To Rule the Waves: How the British Navy Shaped the Modern World is that such a ripe opportunity to use the word "thalassocracy" repeatedly is passed by. (Incidentally, neither Mozilla Firefox's nor MS Word's built-in spell checkers recognize "thalassocracy", which means "rule by sea power", "dominion over the seas", and other such things. Such a word encompasses the height of the British Empire nicely, but the author neglects to use it. So it goes.)Regardless of the author's choice of vocabulary, this is a (relatively) informative introductory history of the British Navy, its origins, its heroes, and the politics that created and sustained it. The narrative begins pre-Francis Drake, and stretches through the Second World War (an epilogue that gives the appearance of being hastily tacked on covers the Falklands War, in the spirit of one last hurrah.) True to the title, there are several examples and instances where naval action helped give rise to the world we know today, and not necessarily in the military strategy sense -- much of this is focused on navigational tools and charts, and the debt the world's mariners owe to the Royal Navy for the pioneering work done in these areas.
While a single paperback-length volume cannot claim to be comprehensive in scope, there are several subjects that I feel are either glossed over, or not treated with the level of detail that they should demand, even in a non-exhaustive work such as this one. Examples of this include the War of 1812 (mentioned in passing during the passages on the Napoleonic Wars), events of the Second World War (mentioned in passing, but much of the section is focused on geopolitics and the role of America. The Bismarck merits only a paragraph(!)), battleship and battlecruiser design (some information on the merits/drawbacks of British design v. German design, taking Jutland into consideration. Additionally, the failures of British design (and re-design) post-Jutland with respect to the Hood), and impressment (a major cause of the War of 1812, and necessary for Britain to maintain a large navy -- but glossed over here. Herman even attempts to rehabilitate the practice!)
Additionally, the final few chapters and the epilogue read as an apologia for naval aims and goals -- any and all factors leading to Britain reducing its empire, or navy is treated with scorn, regardless of justification. Herman overtly takes political sides in these last chapters, and his position as a naval apologist leads to some unorthodox positions -- while the Royal Navy had been a tool for empire in the past, Herman seems to imply that Britain should have maintained an empire solely as a justification for maintaining a large fleet in being. As a practical statement, this is on shaky ground. As a political statement, it's preposterous. While this book is worth reading if you're interested in an overview of the Royal Navy's history (if, for example, you have no idea what the Glorious First of June is), this is probably worth your time. More serious scholars, however, would be advised to look elsewhere.
Labels:
Arthur Herman,
history,
naval history,
non-fiction,
reading,
thalassocracy
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)








